Monday, November 16, 2026

Something New

 We feature each month Nicholas Reid's reviews and comments on new and recent books.   

THE STARVING BRIDE by Catherine Chidgey (Te Herenga Waka University NZ$34.99 )

 


 

I have always admired the novels of Catherine Chidgey. I have read them all, from In a Fishbone Church (her first novel) to her latest. But once again I am behind the pack because I now review novels only each month, and by the time I get to publish my review other pundits have already had there say. Item – in the Listener Stephanie Johnson wrote a review of The Starving Bride telling us it is “aimed squarely at youth, and particularly girls” and later says “although less literary than Chidgey’s previous, the novel does not lack sophistication or complexity”. So that was a very positive review. Item -  Philip Matthews also wrote a review of The Starving Bride. He gave us a detailed account of the novel, but in the end he tells us that “The descent from Remote Sympathy to The Starving Bride is depressing. [Remote Sympathy is one of Catherine Chidgey greatest novels.]  The elements of this plot do not come together in satisfying ways, and as for the central twist, which is a flashback involving a bar of luxury chocolate, it must be one of the most ludicrous and unlikely ideas dreamed up in recent New Zealand fiction. It is just one of the ways in which the book borders on silliness and unseriousness and it is hard to know how to think about it.”

The odd thing is that I partly agree with both pundits. Yes the novel will go down well with teenage girls more than with adults; and yes the adults will see all the flaws in the tail.

A quick synopsis: The novel is set in England, but it is an England that may be somewhere in the future. Hazel is fired from a factory for messing with goods. So she goes to Blackpool which is very crass and tawdry with its seaside amusements. Her best friend is Gilda who is a glamour-puss dancing in Blackpool. Hazel is a little bit weighty. Gilda suggests that Hazel would be perfect as “The Starving Bride”. This [as Chidgey tells us in a note at the end of the novel] was once an amusement in which a slightly weighty young woman would be put into a cage for the crowds to see her asleep - with the idea that she would starve for forty days as the young woman becomes slimmer. [Of course we soon understand that it is a fraud in many ways.] Hazel would like the money so every day the crowds come to see her starving. And to make things even more interesting for the crowd, there is a caged lion next to where Hazel sleeps. Catherine Chidgey gives us much of the chatter and often cruel gossip that goes with the crowd as they try to understand how Hazel survives.

What happens to Hazel is the main interest of the novel. She remembers the unpleasant school girls who used to tease her for her weight, saying she is fat and ugly… and she decides to really starve. But every so often there is another man in the novel, Frank Marsh, who has nothing to do with Hazel. He is a member of the local Borough Council, and he is trying to get them to understand that Blackpool’s famous Tower is rusting away and it will soon collapse. They don’t listen to him or they shout him down - after all, they are more interested in the money they are making.

So much for a general synopsis.

It would wrong to see The Starving Bride as only for teenaged girls. There is much sophistication in the way Chidgey presents the crowd, shows the dishonesty of those who run the shows and the under-handed deals. We understand that friends can also become enemies. But there is much more to the novel. As I see it, this novel is a warning. A group of girls come to admire Hazel because she is dieting and they too want to diet as if this is chique. This comes close to the anorexia nervosa that has plagued many teenage girls – the idea that they have to be extremely slim, sometimes going to the point of killing themselves. And that is what the core of this novel is… as I see it.

I have deliberately simplified Catherine Chidgey’s novel. I do think the ending is melodrama of the sort that teenagers enjoy (the baddies lose etc), but then it is very readable even for grown-ups. Chidgey could appeal to teenagers as well as adults. Having said that, The Starving Bride is not as thoughtful as her best novels The Wish Child, Remote Sympathy, The Book of Guilt and others.

Something Old

Not everything worth reading is hot off the press. In this section, we recommend "something old" that is still well worth reading. "Something Old" can mean anything from a venerable and antique classic to a good book first published year or two ago.  

DEATH COMES FOR THE ARCHBISHOP by Willa Cather (first published in 1927)


 

            It is not my intention to review all of the novels of Willa Cather. As you might have seen, I have reviewed two of her earlier novels, O Pioneers and her best known novel My Antonia. She wrote a total of 13 novels not to mention her many short stories. I have decided to review only two more of her novels… because they are neatly on my shelves. She was always interested in part of the southern parts of the United States, including Nebraska and often near to Mexico, some of which had been taken over by the U.S.A. illegally or otherwise. Her novel Death Comes For The Archbishop surprised some of her readers. First, she grew up in a Baptist family but they were not really interested in religion. Later they became Episcopalians, but with the same attitude. So when Death Comes For The Archbishop came, some Catholics thought she had become a Catholic as the novel is about an almost saintly Catholic priest. They wrote letters to her, asking if she had joined their faith. She politely said she had not, but she said she admired much about the Catholic faith. And she also made it clear that Death Comes For The Archbishop was an historical novel. It was based on the life of a real priest.

Death Comes For The Archbishop begins with a prologue in Rome in 1848 in which three cardinals are aware that the United States have taken over New Mexico. They discuss which priest should go as the leader of the missionary to look after Mexican Catholics. They choose the priest Fr. Jean Marie Latour. [This is a fictious name. The priest’s name was Jean-Baptiste Lamy…. But the novel follows his life carefully]  He is French, a Bishop and a Jesuit – in other words an erudite scholar and able to speak a number of languages. So we plunge into Fr. Jean Marie Latour’s life. In 1851 he is in New Mexico. It is grim and hot when going from town to town and he has to see the Bishop of Durango who is old and a little lax in his work. Latour teaches families who want to have their children baptised and also to get married as most had their children out of wedlock. Latour is given help with another French priest, Father Vaillant, who happens to be a very good cook and there is also Father Joseph. When the hot Mexican sun beats down on them they eat when they can. It is nearly Christmas. Mexicans are always interested in Christmas and come to mass, but they are very rowdy during mass. No matter. Latour sees it as the will of God. And in a chapter called A Bell and a Miracle, Bishop Jean Marie Latour understands the importance for the Mexicans of the miracle of Our Lady of Guadeloupe. The bishop says  “One might almost say that an apparition is human vision corrected by divine love.  I do not see you as you really are, Joseph:  I see you through my affection for you.  The Miracles of the Church seem to me to rest not so much upon faces or voices or healing power coming suddenly near to us from afar off, but upon our perceptions being made finer, so that for a moment our eyes can see and our ears can hear what is there about us always.”

Father Vaillant says Mass to a respectable congregation…but they do not let him baptise their children; Latour has to do it. Often Latour has to go to Albuquerque, to see how a church is being built. In his journeys he runs into some rough and violent people. Latour and Joseph, going to Santa Cruz near the wide valley of the Rio Grande, they meet an American thug who clearly wants to steal whatever they have. They steer clear of him but they learn that his wife is regularly beaten. It is at this point we hear that Kit Carson [a real person and a guider] rescues the mistreated woman; and the thug is finally put to death as he has often killed travellers.



 

  Some years go by. Latour sets up a school for girls so they can read. Latour has to deal with his Superior :  “So far, Bishop Latour had been mainly employed on business that took him far away from his Vicarate.  His great diocese was still an unimaginable mystery to him. He was eager to be abroad in it, to know his people; to escape for a little from the cares of building and founding, and to go westward among the old isolated Indian missions:  Santo Domingo, breeder of horses;  Isleta, whitened with gypsum;  Laguna, of wide pastures;  and, finally, could-set Acoma.”

Latour is aware that many Spanish priests are lazy and do not do what they should be doing, often taking women as their concubines. Latour comes to Padre Martinez. He is a priest who can present the Mass perfectly but he is more interested in money than in enlightening his congregation and he keeps a concubine as well as doing heavy drinking. Father Latour reminds him that he is now in New Mexico, a part of the United States, and can no longer behave as he used to do…. But Latour has to leave Padre Martinez alone as he is called back to a conference in Rome. As it happens, Martinez dies when Latour is away. The new priest who takes over had heard Martinez’s confession and he knew where there was all the money that Martinez had stolen. Earlier in the novel, Father Latour had heard a legend about a Spanish priest who got drunk and had killed a boy who had dropped some food… and seeing this, the Indians killed the priest.

In wild places Jacinto, an Indian, is not only a good guide for Father Latour, but he is very thoughtful and tells much of the nature of the land. “This mesa plain had an appearance of great antiquity, and of incompleteness; as if, with all the materials for world-making assembled, the Creator had desisted, gone away and left everything on the point of being brought together, on the eve of being arranged into mountain, plane, plateau.  The country was still waiting to be made into a landscape. Ever afterward the Bishop remembered his first ride to Acoma as his introduction to the mesa country.  One thing which struck him at once was that every mesa was duplicated by a cloud mesa, like a reflection, which lay motionless above it, or moved slowly up from behind it.  These cloud formations seemed to be always there, however hot and blue the sky.  Sometimes they were flat terraces, ledges of vapour, sometimes they were dome-shaped, or fantastic, like the tops of silvery pagodas, rising one above another, as if an Oriental city lay directly behind the rock.  The great tables of granite set down in an empty plain were inconceivable without their attendant clouds, which were a part of them, as the smoke is part of the censer, or the foam of the wave.”

Latour did say Mass to Apache people and other tribes, but often he went away thinking they had not understood him. With an Indian guide, Latour later found his way to a huge cavern which seemed to be a place where Indians held their own sacred ceremonies…. And for a while he thought that this was also a sacred place.

Again time goes by. By this stage, the U.S.A. is well on the way to taking over New Mexico and Arizona. “By the Gladsden Purchase, executed three years after Father Latour came to Santa Fe, the United States took over from Mexico a great territory which now forms southern New Mexico and Arizona.”

  Bishop Jean Marie Latour, now on his way to being an Archbishop, tells his younger priests that they must make many changes under a new country. But some American things were obnoxious. Mexico had banned slavery; but in some parts of the U.S.A. some Americans still had slaves. Latour helped an old slaved woman to be freed from her masters.

In his later years, Latour came to know very well the Navajo people, often spoke with them, and found them to be very pacifistic, quite un-like the more war-like Apache people. Towards of the end of his life, when he was an Archbishop, Latour had to deal with young men who were going to a gold-rush and he made two priest go with them to make sure they were not ruined by drink and other sins. Latour also found other priests to build a church in Denver. He was ever concerned for the way the Navajo and Apache people were having their lands being taken. Says Willa Cather : “For many years Father Latour used to wonder if there would ever be an end to the Indian wars while there was one Navajo or Apache left alive.  Too many traders and manufacturers made a rich profit out of that warfare;  a political machine and immense capital were employed to keep it going.”

            After reading Death Comes For The Archbishop, I found this novel to be more chronical than novel. Willa Cather is giving us history based on a real person, Jean-Baptiste Lamy, put together from events she had researched carefully. As for the title, it is typical of her to come up with Death Comes For The Archbishop. It might make people think that something strange had happened to the Archbishop, but in fact it was an ordinary death.  

 



Something Thoughtful

  

                         DO WE REALLY TEACH LITERATURE?

 

Dear readers, I am going to cheat you. I am giving you here what I had written in my very first comment in my blog 15 years ago. I have not changed a word.

 

A question has been jangling in my head recently and keeping me awake at night.

 

Is the appreciation of literature really being taught?

 

I know at first glance the question seems self-evidently absurd. Of course the appreciation of literature can be taught. Otherwise why do we have all those English and other language departments and programmes in universities and colleges? And why do high-school teachers force Lord of the Flies,  The God Boy, The Colour Purple, To Kill a Mockingbird, The Old Man and the Sea, Man Alone, The Scarlet Letter into young and unwilling heads?

 

But think carefully about the question and you’ll see there is a real problem. If the appreciation of literature means responding perceptively to what authors have actually written, then is it really being taught?

 

Let me illuminate the problem by telling you what I know about a specific writer.

 

I’m quite knowledgeable about Elizabeth Gaskell and her novels. I know that she was not quite up there with classics like Dickens, George Eliot and Thackeray, but that she was an esteemed Victorian writer who has retained a considerable readership. I know that she is now much lauded by feminist academics because she gave a distinctly female account of early industrialised England. I know she wrote Mary Barton, Cranford, North and South, Wives and Daughters and other novels and short stories of small town, industrial town and domestic life; and I know that some of her work first appeared as serials in periodicals like Household Words and All the Year Round.

 

If you sat me down in front of a school exam question on Elizabeth Gaskell, or confronted me with an undergraduate essay topic on her, I’d be able to concoct a creditable answer. I could sagely discuss her themes – the circumscribed lives of women; the power of gossip; the  clash of older village ways with industrialisation in England’s “railway age”; the beginnings of wage slavery; class divisions between the squirearchy and the middle classes; the ties that bind small communities together and so forth. I could name her main characters, write accounts of them, and neatly précis her plots. I could even make some apt comments on her style and her tendency to focus on the minutiae of life. All this would be off the top of my head from what I already know. Give me spend and hour or two to look some reference material, and I’d do even better.

 

But here’s the rub. Although it pains me to admit it, and although I should be performing ritualised penance, I have never read a single word of Elizabeth Gaskell’s works, even though three of her books sit on my shelves as I write this.

 

Having never got around to her, I have simply accumulated knowledge of her from other sources. These include passing references in general histories of literature; what I have heard other people say about her; enthusiastic recommendations from an Elizabeth Gaskell fan whom I knew some years back; and my having seen two BBC TV serial adaptations of her work – North and South and Cranford.

 

Everything I know about Elizabeth Gaskell is second-hand. My eyes have never travelled across the words she actually wrote and I’ve never experienced or assessed how she wrote.

 

Which brings me back to my original question – is the appreciation of literature really being taught?

 

After all, if the study of literature is supposed to be training our responses to the process of reading itself, to a particular writer’s style, and to the impact of the words on the page, then plot summaries, character studies, background sociological or biographical detail, what eminent critics have thought and the neat corralling of themes all have very little to do with it. Those things can be acquired without ever bothering to read whatever is supposedly being studied. They are a form of knowledge, but they are not an appreciation of literature.

 

I’m not exposing any obscure trade secret in noting this. The world is filled with high school students and perhaps a majority of BA students who have negotiated literature courses not by reading the set texts, but only by reading “study guides” on the model of the old Cole’s Notes or  Monarch Notes, or by accessing whatever Wikipedia and the ‘net have to say. Conning lecturer’s notes always helps, too. (Our Humanities departments are so constituted that it is always wise to flatter your lecturer’s opinions when you formulate your answers.)

 

Regrettably, these methods will often be the very ones that earn an A+. Real literature for adults is allusive, can be read on many levels, and does not often lend itself to simple interpretations of the sort that one dashes off against the clock in exam or term-paper conditions. The student who has dutifully ploughed through, puzzled over and personally responded to something compendious like Bleak House may well be at a disadvantage in comparison with the student who has memorised by heart ready-made phrases about style, plot, character, themes, historical significance and so forth. I have often enough been on the other side of the fence as a (secondary- and tertiary-level) marker, and I know that a forthright, organised, clearly-expressed, information-packed answer will usually trump a sincere but more tortuous answer. Clarity and a genuine personal response to a text are not mutually-exclusive. Yet the organised, clearly-expressed answer is more likely to be the parroted answer.

 

I am reminded of a true story Solzhenitsyn once reported. An official Soviet-era manual advised students not to bother reading Tolstoy or Dostoievsky, but just to read the summaries of their novels given in the manual. The books themselves would be too “confusing”. Soviet officials may well have had ideological objections to undiluted Tolstoy and Dostoievsky, with all their religious and non-materialist concerns. But the manual’s advice was a frank admission of the same process that is encouraged by our own pedagogy. I’m further reminded of how often, over the years, I have heard blowhards boasting that they won high grades in school and university courses just by memorising bits of a “study guide”. Usually this has been said to me as if it were a sign of the speaker’s extreme cleverness. In fact it merely references a game whose rules all teachers and academics fully understand.

 

There are some fairly obvious responses to what I am saying.

 

One would be to ask whether any of it matters. After all, if high school or tertiary students of literature are gaining credits in NCEA courses, or passing their examinations, then what does it matter how they acquired the relevant knowledge? This approach appeals to principals whose chief concern is making their schools look good in a competitive market (between schools, NCEA is just as competitive as older national examination systems were). It appeals equally to supervisors of tertiary academic programmes, whose funding relies on a successful through-put of as many students as possible. But it implicitly negates the whole reason for studying literature in the first place. It says that a real encounter with an author’s written words is less important than knowledge about those written words. Literature is reduced to useless data, encouraging many students to regard the whole concept with contempt and to avoid ever reading anything challenging again, once they have their degree or certificate.

 

Another response would be to point out that I am really talking about means of assessment rather the study of literature itself. What about those teachers who ask students to compile reading journals, or to compose personal and subjective responses to what they are set to read? What about those who devise tests and exercises that require recall of a text’s actual wording? What about seminars which challenge students’ understanding and discuss specific given passages of a text?

 

I concede that assessment of students is one of the main things that concerns me. I acknowledge, too, that the more advanced the level of study, the less easy it becomes to hide behind ready-made packages of other peoples’ summaries. Generally, high-school students and undergraduates can get away with it, but at the postgraduate level it is much harder. (Not that it is impossible, mind. And a little creative re-wording can usually circumvent the electronic guards that most universities now use to prevent outright plagiarism in students’ work.).

 

But I am still on firm ground when I note the prevalence of pretending to teach literature itself, while actually encouraging students to value facts and opinions about literature. Some years ago, as a conscientious high-school teacher, I used to read the “model” essays that were sent out to us as examples of the best students’ work in the old Bursary and Scholarship English exams. I became rapidly disillusioned as I noted how many of them could have been written without even opening the works that were supposedly being analysed. One such “model” essay, earning top marks, was a collection of well-ordered, clearly-expressed current clichés about the role of women in literature. It had only a peripheral relationship with the Virginia Woolf novel that it was ostensibly discussing. Doubtless the student who wrote it was a very intelligent 17-year-old (or Year 13) student. Doubtless, too, she had carefully memorised everything her teacher had told her. But she was not responding to literature. She was repeating something that had been squeezed out of literature before she got to it.

 

I could pile up the depressing anecdotes along these lines. I once met a high-school teacher at a training day who proudly circulated materials he gave his senior classes, telling them that “there are two ways to study a novel”. One was to read the novel. The other, which he recommended to his students as less laborious, was to watch a good film or television adaptation of the novel and then read a study guide. So much for encountering the words on the page. Then there was the lecturer who claimed that it was unimportant for him to read the works on which he lectured. All that mattered was that he knew the work’s cultural significance, its place in literary history and the chief critical arguments and controversies it had aroused. In effect, the lecturer gave second-hand opinions to his students who (unless they took the unusual expedient of doing their own reading) would eventually give him back third-hand answers.

 

And so on and so on.

 

In our senior national high-school Bursary and Scholarship English exams, there used to be a compulsory “unseen” question, in which students had to interpret a poem or piece of prose they were seeing for the first time. It was the one part of the paper that challenged them to demonstrate their own reading skills and perception, as opposed to regurgitating what they had been told. Of course it was eventually judged to be too hard for too many students, and ceased to be compulsory. So it was back to a paper which encouraged students to write what they had been told about literature, rather than what they had personally experienced of it. I am, however, encouraged that a similar “unseen” interpretation question is now part of NCEA exams.

 

As a teacher, one of my preferred forms of torture was to photocopy extracts from the novel my class was studying, and then make the students, under test conditions, identify where it came from, what it meant and what the passage displayed that was typical of the author’s style. Perhaps one day I will get around to reading Elizabeth Gaskell. I might then be able to answer such contextual quizzing about her. In the meantime, having not read  single word of hers, I am fully equipped to pass whatever standard test a standard literature course on her could throw at me.

 

I know at least as much as an A+ student would.

PS By the way, since I wrote this 15 years ago, I have read some of Elizabeth Gaskell’s works.

PPS Part of my reason in writing about all this came after I had seen on television on the night that we were all seeing who would become prime-minister.  A smug member of parliament said that when he was in school he just saw a movie of the book he was supposed to have read at school  - and he passed with honours…. Which is why too many school-teachers really don’t teach literature at all.

Monday, October 19, 2026

Something New

  We feature each month Nicholas Reid's reviews and comments on new and recent books.  

FAST by Jorie Graham (first published in 2017) ; BLACK GOLD by Mark Pirie  (published by Earl of Seacliff Ark Workshop, NZ$30)

 

A good friend of mine sent me a copy of Jorie Graham’s Fast. At first I thought it must be a new collection of poetry - but then I looked at the press and I realised that it had been around for quite a while. In my ignorance I knew nothing about the poet, maybe because I have spent most of my recent time reviewing New Zealand, Australian and English poetry.  So I did what most reviewers do. I looked up who Jorie Graham was. Some facts – she is an American, but she grew up in Europe. She is now 77 years old. She has produced 15 collections of poetry. She taught at Harvard for years, and she has won many prizes like the Pulitzer. In her private life she has gone through three husbands and when she was younger she was traumatized by the death of her mother. And having said all this, I am sure that any poetry-reader in America would see me as an ignorant person. Jorie Graham is widely known and read in America.

            The poem Ashes shows how much of her writing is about working out who she herself is  - in other words she is uncertain of her identity “I spend a lifetime entering – the question of place hanging over me year after year…” but at the same time she is intrigued by animals. This idea continues in the following poem Honeycomb where she is examining the nature of human beings. She often writes in brief comments as in the poem Self Portrait at Three Degrees when she tells us “I cannot love any more….. I can’t hold it any more – you don’t want it – I don’t care…” etc. The poem Shroud seems to deal with either her mother or another woman. In The Enmeshments she appears to be having a fleeting moment where she wishes she had some standard to stand on thus “ Spellbound by the history – of god – unknowing – I feel my theory collapsing – I say I – I say too early too soon – the Greeks perhaps they say…” In other contexts she writes about “bots” - how we are being taken over by machines. There is also Reading to My Father, in which she writes something about her relationship with her father when she was a child. While I was confused by most of  the long poem The Medium, I was impressed by the final words “The day is long. It flirts with nothingness. It always does”, a genuine nihilism shown. I am also impressed by the poem Vigil where she gives us a very vivid image of the sun rising where “Daylight shows it. It pierces us with its red spear. It widens… run, it is day, run everywhere.” As for the poems With Mother in the Kitchen and Dementia we get to two images of a family’s tragedy. As for the poem To Tell of Bodies Changed to Different Forms we are told “We will never be happy with the body. Will exchange it for another.” 

            So I could continue with comments and ideas. Jorie Graham has many interesting things to say and she does have moments of earnestness. She is certainly worried about the nature of the current United States. Having said all this though, I find her style very difficult to follow. Too often – she writes – like this – as if – we are meant to – hold on to little statements – that could – have been said – more clearly – or could – have been expanded…

            By which I mean that it is very hard to understand what most of her poems are saying. 

 *.  *.  *.  *.  *.  *.  *.  *.  * .  *.   *.   *.  *.  * . *.  *.  *.  *.  *. 

 

 Turning to a completely different collection of poems comes Black Gold by Mark Pirie. He is a New Zealander and he dedicated this collection to the long-gone James K. Baxter. Pirie has much wit, knows much about New Zealand history and is concerned with many things. Read the wrong way you might think that he is flippant. Take for example The Great New Zealand Poetry Debate which reads in full “It happened at some point. / It was well organised and well run / with very few attendees, / most choosing to ignore it.” Could it mean that not many people read poetry? Or could it mean that some very good poets are ignored? Or could it mean quite a number of things?

Pirie dedicates many of his poems to poets. The collection’s name Black Gold is dedicated to Clive James. Pirie writes “Black Gold / is the name / of my Notebook. / It’s apt for poetry. / Poets mine / for gold in the hills/rivers / of similes, metaphors, symbols, / onomatopoeia, rhetoric, metonymy… / What does it take / to find that nugget / that will bring riches: / distinction or fame?” In the poem The Song Maker, dedicated to Richard Reeve, he says “ Like Baxter / and Curnow, you seek elaborate but traditional / forms to contain your philosophy, the mind’s / colossus. You are digging into the mud, / into the beach sand, the pumice, driftwood / and sea-bark. You are your own song.” And I must add that he is dead right.

A section of this collection deals with personal memories of family - Grandmother, being taken to the shops when he was a kid, the whole life of his Grandfather, holidays, and an interesting poem about Ghosts, as seen by children.

He moves on to other poets… poems about meeting Hone Tuwhare and a very heartfelt  poem about the death of the Maori Queen. But he is at his best when he writes poems about historical events in New Zealand, such as the Ballantyne fire, the Depression and the work of Edward Tregear…. And there is much more. I greatly enjoyed this collection, open minded, sometimes happy, sometimes angry, but always very readable.


 

Somthing Old

    Not everything worth reading is hot off the press. In this section, we recommend "something old" that is still well worth reading. "Something Old" can mean anything from a venerable and antique classic to a good book first published year or two ago.  

MY ANTONIA by Willa Cather (first published in 1918)

            After writing O Pioneers Willa Cather wrote another novel set in Nebraska called The Song of the Lark. After this came My Antonia, much of which also deals with struggling farmers; but unlike the first two novels, My Antonia is also set as much in the towns as in the fields. These three novels are often called “The Prairie Trilogy”, but when My Antonia was first published in 1918 it was immediately seen in America as a masterpiece. It is still read in American high-schools and colleges and it is still being regularly published. This time, Willa Cather makes the central narrator a man –  perhaps because Willa Cather herself had a male demeanour.

            Jim Burden – the narrator - is an orphan who has come from Virginia. His cousins live in Nebraska and that is where he is sent. His Grandmother and Grandfather look after him well, they have a good house in Black Hawk and they also farm. The family’s hired man is a German man, Otto Fuchs. Young Jim gets to understand how hawks behave, watching  out for rattle-snakes, and helping his Grandmother dig up potatoes. How he loves the earth when he gets used to it. And Jim gets to be interested in the soil itself. He says “The earth was warm under me, and warm as I crumbled it through my fingers.  Queer little red bugs came out and moved in slow squadrons around me.  Their backs were polished vermilion, with black spots. I kept as still as I could.  Nothing happened.  I did not expect anything to happen.  I was something that lay under the sun and felt it, like the pumpkins, and I did not want to be anything more.  I was entirely happy.  Perhaps we feel like that when we die and become a part of something entire, whether it is sun and air, or goodness and knowledge.  At any rate, that is happiness; to be dissolved into something complete and great.”

            He is introduced to a Bohemian family the Shimerdas, who are Catholic. Unlike the Burdens, they are very poor. They do not have a house. They live in a dug-out built of clay and they shelter their few animals in their house. Jim Burden in introduced to this family - a mother who is always angry that they live in such a poor house and who envies the Burdens; a father, Krajiek, who is getting old and often laments that they had left Poland; and a rather aggressive son called Ambrosch who hopes he will become a great farmer. But the youngest of the family is Antonia. She is a little older than Jim but not much. She is learning the English language slowly and better than the rest of her family. Jim takes to her, teaches her the English language better and the two of them often go walking in the fields and rambling near the streams and sometimes visiting people. Jim sees her as his best friend. But  “Much as I liked Antonia, I hated a superior tone that she sometimes took with me. She was four years older than I, to be sure, and had seen more of the world;  but I was a boy and she was a girl, and I resented her protecting manner. Before the autumn was over, she began to treat me more like an equal and to defer to me in other things than reading lessons.  This change came about from an adventure we had together.  One day when I rode over to the Shimerdas’ I found Antonia starting off on foot for Russian Peter’s house, to borrow a spade Ambrosch needed.  I offered to take her on the pony, and she got up behind me.  There had been another black frost the night before, and the air was clear and heady as wine.  Within a week all the blooming roads had been despoiled, hundreds of miles of yellow sunflowers had been transformed into brown, rattling, burry stalks.” 

            In one ramble, Jim kills a rattle-snake which came too near to Antonia…. but there are other things that Jim hears of. There are two Russian brothers, Peter and Pavel, and he hears from them the hair-raising story of a crowd of people, in their way to a wedding feast, being attacked and killed by wolves in old Russia. Jim also hears from old-timers about the “Indians” who used to be in the prairie nearby, but they are no longer there.

            The winter is very, very cold – so much so that the creeks freeze over… but there is some joy at Christmas. The Burden family take gifts to the Shimerdas and for some time there is joy… but the father, Krajiek Shimerda, is more and more despairing, wishing he was still in his home country, believing they will get nowhere, and some months later he commits suicide. How is Krajiek going to be buried? There is no Catholic priest nearby but the Catholics get together and bury him carefully, say prayers, and some Protestants sing hymns.

            By this stage both Antonia and Jim are growing into adolescence. Antonia is working in the fields. It is very hard work. For a short time there is a fight between Ambrosch – her brother - and the worker Jake, but Antonia smooths it over and she keeps on working.

Jim was very amazed by the hard work that Antonia does. “If I rode over to see her where she was ploughing, she stopped at the end of a row to chat for a moment, then gripped her plough-handles, clucked to her team, and waded on down the furrow, making me feel that she was now grown up and had no time for me.  On Sundays she helped her mother make garden or sewed all day.   Grandfather was pleased with Antonia.  When we complained of her, he only smiled and said, ‘She will help some fellow get ahead in the world.”   Nowadays Tony could talk of nothing but the prices of things, or how much she could lift and endure.  She was too proud of her strength.  I knew, too, that Ambrosch put upon her some chores a girl ought not to do, and that the farm-hands around the country joked in a nasty way about it.  Whenever I saw her come up the furrow, shouting to her beasts, sunburned, steady, her dress open at the neck, and her throat and chest dust-plastered, I used to think of the tone in which poor Mr. Shimerda, who could say so little, yet managed to say so much when he exclaimed, ‘My Antonia!’  ”

Time goes by. Otto and Jake go away and are never seen again. Aged 13, Jim is sent to school in Black Hawk, where is grandfather is a Baptist deacon. By this time, Antonia no longer works in the fields. She is working in the town for Mrs. Harling, basically as a maid. Jim often visits the Harling family. At which point we are introduced to the Swedish girl Lena Lingard. She causes much bother and almost scandal because the young men are bewitched by her… and wives are angry as she is such a flirt. Lena wants to get away from being a cow-herder and she aims to work for a dressmaker in the town.

Then “Winter comes down savagely over a little town on the prairie.  The wind that sweeps in from the open country strips away all the leafy screens that hide one yard from another in summer, and the houses seem to draw closer together.  The roofs, that looked so far away across the green tree-tops, now stare you in the face, and they are so much uglier than when their angles were softened by vines and shrubs.   In the morning, when I was fighting my way to school against the wind, I couldn’t see anything but the road in front of me;  but in the late afternoon, when I was coming home, the town looked bleak and desolate to me.  The pale, cold light of the winter sunset did not beautify – it was like the light of truth itself.  When the smoky clouds hung low in the west and the red sun went down behind them, leaving a pink flush on the snowy roofs and the blue drifts, then the wind sprang up afresh, with a kind of bitter song, as if it said:  “This is reality, whether you like it or not.  All those frivolities of summer, the light and shadow, the living mask of green that trembled over everything, they were lies, and this is what was underneath.  This is the truth.’  It was as if we were being punished for loving the loveliness of summer”

We understand how Antonia thinks of her mistress Mrs. Harling. “There was a basic harmony between Antonia and her mistress.  They had strong, independent natures, both of them. They knew what they liked, and were not always trying to imitate other people.  They loved children and animals and music, and rough play and digging in the earth.   They liked to prepare rich, hearty food and to see people eat it; to make up soft white beds and to see youngsters asleep in them.  They ridiculed conceited people and were quick to help unfortunate ones.  Deep down in each of them there was a kind of hearty joviality, a relish of life, not over-delicate, but very invigorating.  I never tried to define it, but I was distinctly conscious of it.  I could not imagine Antonia’s living for a week in any other house in Black Hawk than the Harlings’.”

Comes summer and there is a kind of festival where Danes, Italians, Swedes, Bohemians and others gather together. More girls are now leaving the farms and finding work in the town where they are paid well. Antonia, Lena and three other Bohemian girls now work in the town. Antonia leaves the Harling house because Mrs. Harling is too severe and will not let her and other girls go to a dance…. And after this she goes back to working in the farm…. By this stage Jim is about to go to [what Americans call] College … but first there is an unpleasant fight between Wick Cutter, a nasty money-lender, and Jim who is badly beaten. But off he goes to College. By this stage we see the gap between a young working woman (Antonia) and a young middle-class man (Jim) on his way to being a lawyer.

Now at Lincoln University Jim has a very helpful tutor, Gaston Cleric, who is head of the Latin Department [remember that right up to the late-twentieth century lawyers had to know all Latin terms]. Perhaps Gaston Cleric was too fixed to ancient poetry… and then Jim is surprised that Lena Lingard is also working in Lincoln. She is doing well and she runs a dressmaking store. She visits him a number of times.  Indeed they go to plays together often – and they are both moved by a performance of  “Camille” [which says something about the tastes of the late 19th century.]. But they are friends only. Indeed Lena makes it clear that she never wants to marry any man. Lena tells him about how Antonia is getting on. Apparently Antonia has a boyfriend back in Black Hawk. By now Jim is 19. He is reluctant to say good-by to Lena.   He is on his way to Harvard… and well on his way to being a lawyer.

Jim visits Black Hawk again. he sees that “The wheat harvest was over, and here and there along the horizon I could see black puffs of smoke from the steam threshing-machines. The old pasture land was now being broken up into wheatfields and cornfields, the red grass was disappearing, and the whole face of the country was changing.  There were wooden houses where the old sod dwellings used to be, and little orchards, and big red barns; all this meant happy children, contented women, and men who saw their lives coming to a fortunate issue. The windy springs and the blazing summers, one after another, had enriched and mellowed that flat tableland;  all the human effort that had gone into it was coming back in long, sweeping lines of fertility.  The changes seemed beautiful and harmonious to me; it was like watching the growth of a great man or of a great idea.  I recognized every tree and sandbank and rugged draw.  I found that I remembered the conformation of the land as one remembers the modelling of human faces.”


 

Under the heading “The Pioneer Woman’s Story” Jim learns about Antonia when he visits Black Hawk again. Hers was a tragic one. Her boyfriend had promised to marry her and said he had much wealth – but before she was married she was pregnant and her man ran away. He had claimed to be wealthy, but that was a lie. She went back to her Bohemian family where they looked after her and they welcomed the new child. They had prospered by hard work. Jim, visiting from Harvard, drops in on Antonia and once again he remembered their youth when they walked in the fields…. Years later Jim, now a prospering lawyer, once again visits Antonia. She is now married to a Bohemian man Anton Cuzak and – being good Catholics – they have ten children who are also hard workers. Once again Jim and Antonia talk of their childhood. When he goes back to his work, he can’t help thinking of her as “My Antonia”.

What I have given you is a mere synopsis. Among other things, there are stories that are not central to the novel. There is, for example, the story of Wick Cutter, the nasty money-lender, who kills his wife just before he dies rather than letting her have any money after he has gone. And there is the brief tale of d’Arnault, the Negro pianist who entertains hotels. And all the while Willa Cather celebrates the many ethnicities who have come to the United States.

There is a strong possibility that anyone first seeing a book called My Antonia would think that it is going to be a romantic novel about two lovers. Far from it. What Willa Cather does is showing us two strong women who have made they way in the world in spite of difficulties. Lena Lingard has decided that she does not want to be pawed by men and has made her way as an entrepreneur in the town. Antonia has always wanted to be a mother and have a family, as well as knowing the necessity of work. Both of them have reached their goal. In that respect My Antonia is a feminist novel. Note too that the novel has a man as the narrator… but maybe this shows how much Willa Cather prefers women.

Something Thoughtful

   Nicholas Reid reflects in essay form on general matters and ideas related to literature, history, popular culture and the arts, or just life in general. You are free to agree or disagree with him.   

                        CAN YOU READ REAL NOVELS?

I don’t know if you saw some weeks back an article written in the Listener by a woman called Leah McFall. She was amused by the fact that, whenever she is traveling in a plane, people are surprised that she would be reading a book. Others would simply be watching a film or scrolling their phones. Reading a novel is not thought of.

Isn’t it true that reading real novels [not kiddies books, not short stories in magazines] has become passe? Yes, there are still many novels being published and many readers, but not as many as there used to be. Why should this be so?  Obviously there is for some people the lure of movies, television and phones to be scrolled… but this leads to not reading long books and especially not reading classical books [by which I mean books written in the 18th, 19th and 20th  centuries]. In the United States, it has recently been shown again and again that students who come to university to study the humanities now find it difficult to read full-length novels, whether it is Harvard, Princeton or any other illustrious university. Previously students had to read at least one full-length classical novel each week, and then critique it. Now this is seen as too difficult for the students. And two things happen. A: students look up  synopses of the book rather than reading the book; or B: lecturers give them “notes” about the novels rather than reading the book.  Recently I came across an essay written by a young woman, an American student, who was deeply upset that her tutors said you didn’t have to read any book in full because it was too difficult. She thought that she was being cheated.

Alas, this is not only an American phenomenon. It is seen in New Zealand and elsewhere. Some many years back, when I was a high-school teacher, I went to a teachers-only day in which we were to think up ideas to help teenagers understand literature. One bright fellow said that reading can be too difficult for teenagers, so what you should do is pick a novel that has been turned into a movie, show the movie, then give the class some notes about how the movie was different from the original book. See folks – you don’t have to read the book at all. All of which means that many school-children grow up thinking that books are boring anyway… and literature in unimportant. Wonder why, in Auckland’s University, few people now choose literature as their major?